Friday, February 6, 2009

BOOK: Daughter of Fortune by Isabel Allende

Daughter of Fortune by Isabel Allende, 399 pages

translated from the Spanish by Margaret Sayers Peden



genre challenge: historical fiction; Latin America Challenge: Chile

Eliza Sommers, orphaned at birth and raised in Valparaiso, Chile and Tao Chi'en, a Chinese doctor meet on a boat on the way to the California gold rush of 1849. Each of them get a background treatment, with a history of Chile, and China and their respective lives. They each get a love story before they meet and it was all very well written and engrossing.

It should have been fabulous, but it fell a bit short for me, and yet I still liked it. I always felt a bit detached from Eliza through the narration. At times I would start to get into her head and feel her emotions, but I never got all the way there so that I was really rooting for her. Tao Chi'en life was better explained and was able to connect a bit better him. A few hints or foreshadowing also prevented some of the big reveals from losing their punch because it was foretold. There were several subplots that felt rushed in their closing, I am thinking of the aunt's erotic writings that just appeared and nothing happened with it other than it happened. Why didn't Eliza ever find out about it? The ending itself was very anti-climatic and I was left wondering if I had missed something.

Those criticisms aside, the historical aspect was very well done, especially the travel between Chile and California, and the gold rush experience. I was never bored while reading and I would read another by Allende. She treated the women well and the role women in those rough times was examined. Strong females who found a way to live life on their own terms when that couldn't have been easy. It was a great opening book for the Latin American Challenge.

5 comments:

Staci said...

I read this a while ago but I did enjoy it. She wrote a YA series that I really liked a lot too... City of Beasts...http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3304.City_of_the_Beasts

Kailana said...

I read this book years ago and really liked it. I have been considering a reread, but haven't got there yet. Portrait of Sepia is a sequel, of sorts, if you are interested. I read that a while ago, too, so I can't really remember what happens. All I do remember is that I liked Daughter of Fortune the better of the two.

Marg said...

I liked this one when I read it. I wasn't so keen on the sequel.

SuziQoregon said...

I listened to this one (read by Blair Brown). I felt exactly like this about it.
"It should have been fabulous, but it fell a bit short for me, and yet I still liked it."

samantha.1020 said...

I've been meaning to give this author a try for awhile now. Great review! I might give this one a try for my historical fiction challenge.